What I like -good scrub, not too oily not too dry , just good for my skin-after use , my skin has light olive fragrance, like it!-the walnut shell particles are more gentle than St Ives Apricot Scrub Things can be improved -the fragrance is a bit strong during use-the tub if is in dark amber glass jar will make this product more "class" - no spatula ( Origins Modern Friction for Body has 1 spoon to scoop)